OP and I were in the same boat. I just got my compos yesterday...and I'm happy with them. I read everything here and just made the executive decision not to suffer from analysis paralysis. The compo and a 265/65/18 appears to be a completely proven package here so that's what I'm doing. Hope to get my black 19"s for sale soon as I get the truck.
Now OP, once you choose your wheels, it's TIRE time! BFG A/T or save a few bucks and go Terra Grappler G2 in LT rating. Decisions Decisions for us new folk.
