Pirelli ATR VS Hankook Ventus AS RH07

[Learth]

I've narrowed my choice to these 2 tires for my 19" wheels. Things that are most important to me:
1) Quiet ride on pavement
2) Long tread life
3) Decent in the snow

Which would you choose?

 

[nwoods]

That's sort of like what my clients ask in our new construction projects. They want it 1) Cheaper, 2) Faster, 3) Better.

My answer is always the same, chose any two.

 

[kingfishgrapeja]

I have the hankooks. They were great in the snow, but they were only a couple of months old then are still quiet after 13k and look like I have another 10 left. I have never had the pirelli's

 

[goinsurfin]

From experience, I'll pick 2 and say the ATRs are still very quiet and yes, you'll get lots of life out of them. Right now i have over 33k miles since Jan 09 and they wear nicely. Note, my driving 90% on road in SoFl. As for snow, I don't recall how they handle but check the tirerack review for reference.