I am not familiar with the design of the 2014+ bumper down there (2013 here), but your photos are confusing the heck out of me.

There are several side shots of the Asfir front guard (I think), seemingly mounted in place, but the removable bumper cover for the tow ring is showing through the hole - was it not removed prior to installation? I don't see how the Asfir guard could sit nearly flush against the lower bumper as intended with that cover in place - which may or may not have contributed to the damage you seem to have suffered, not sure. At the very least, I imagine your approach angle would be negatively affected.
Regardless, other than the weight savings, the nice thing about an aluminum plate is that, unless it is cracked or bent beyond reason, it can generally be removed, hammered back in shape and reinstalled.
Finally, those silly aerodynamic plastic "winglets" in front of the tire should be removed if you are going to do any type of serious or semi-serious off-roading, as they will just get in the way and probably tear / break the first time they brush against an obstacle other than grass...